The Fantastic Four and Superman: A Tale of Two Babies by @storymapsdan
A Bundle of Joy and a Dumptruck full of Doodads:
The Fantastic Four steps on Superman
by Daniel Calvisi
It’s all about that “core” conflict
It’s late summer 2025 and the two big superhero movies of the season have come out: Superman from DC and The Fantastic Four: First Steps from Marvel. At the box-office, the films had very similar domestic and international openings, but it’s clear Superman is having more staying power at the cinema.
That’s too bad, because, creatively, I believe Fantastic Four is a much better film than Superman, and its success began with a foundation of solid writing choices (ironic, considering that Superman had one writer and Fantastic Four had several writers and even went through an arbitration process to decide final credits). Both films are visually stunning, but it’s the story and characters that make Fantastic Four stand out to me.
I must admit, I wasn’t always this bully on the prospect of a new FF movie. In the run-up to the release, I definitely had my doubts. I was worried about reports that we wouldn’t see their origin but rather join the FF already in action as a successful world-saving superhero team. I was worried about the retro-style and the story being set in an alternate universe outside of the core MCU films. But mostly, I was flummoxed as to why they were including Sue Storm’s pregnancy so early in the saga. In the original comics by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, she doesn’t become pregnant with Franklin Richards until years into the run. It seemed like the perfect ending to this film would be Sue saying “I’m pregnant.” Cut to credits.
Oh boy, was I wrong to worry. The baby was the BEST thing that could have happened to this film. Not only was it unique to have a superhero movie revolve around a pregnancy, but the brilliant “core” conflict of the film is built around it, and this core conflict is the greatest strength of The Fantastic Four: First Steps. Everything else is window dressing. Read more